DAPENALAW
Call (813) 930-5422

Florida underpaid property insurance claim lawyer

They paid you. That is not the same as covering it.

An underpayment is harder to see than a denial, because a check arrived. The number on it is usually the product of depreciation, a scope that missed items, and a price list that does not match what a contractor in your county will actually charge.

ACV vs RCV
§ 627.7011Replacement cost, and when the holdback is released
Pay or deny within
60 daysOf proof of loss, absent factors beyond the insurer’s control
Supplemental claim
18 monthsFor hurricane and windstorm losses. § 627.70132
Free mediation
§ 627.7015Through the Department of Financial Services, paid by the insurer

01 Where the money goes missing

Why a Florida insurance payment comes in under the real cost

An actual cash value payment is replacement cost minus depreciation. On a replacement cost policy that depreciation is normally recoverable once the work is done and documented — and a great deal of it is never claimed, because nobody told the policyholder it was being held back.

The second gap is scope. The adjuster’s estimate is a list of line items, and what is not on the list is not paid for. Matching materials, code upgrades, detach-and-reset, and the labor sequence a real repair requires are routinely thin or missing.

The third is pricing. Carrier estimates are generated from software price lists. Whether those numbers reflect what a licensed contractor in Miami-Dade or Hillsborough will actually sign a contract for is a question of evidence, and the evidence is a contractor’s written estimate.

02 The clause nobody reads

How the appraisal clause works in a Florida property policy

Most Florida property policies contain an appraisal provision. Each side names an appraiser, those two choose an umpire, and an award is entered on the amount of the loss. It is faster and cheaper than litigation and it exists in the policy the insurer wrote.

Its limit matters: appraisal resolves how much, not whether the loss is covered at all. Where the carrier disputes coverage outright, appraisal is the wrong tool.

03 Situations this covers

These are examples of circumstances people find themselves in, not accounts of particular cases. Every claim is decided on its own policy and its own facts.

  • A check arrives for less than the deductible-adjusted estimate, with depreciation withheld and no explanation of how to recover it.
  • The scope covers the damaged slope of a roof but not the matching required to make the repair uniform.
  • A contractor’s written estimate is two or three times the carrier’s line-item figure for the same work.
  • Code upgrades required by the county before a permit will issue appear nowhere in the estimate.

04 What damages a claim

  • Cashing the check and assuming that closes the claim — it usually does not, but the file goes quiet.
  • Never claiming the recoverable depreciation after the work is completed.
  • Letting the supplemental deadline run while negotiating informally.
  • Signing a contractor’s assignment without understanding what it gives away.

Frequently asked questions about Florida underpaid claims

I already cashed the check. Did I accept the amount?

Usually not. A payment on a claim is not ordinarily a settlement unless you signed a release saying so.

Read anything you signed alongside it. A release, a sworn proof of loss stating a final figure, or a settlement agreement are different from an ordinary claim payment.

What is recoverable depreciation?

On a replacement cost policy the insurer first pays actual cash value — the cost to replace, minus depreciation for age and wear. The withheld portion is released once the repair is actually completed and documented.

A great deal of it is never collected, because the policyholder was never told it was waiting.

Have a denied Florida insurance claim reviewed

English or Spanish. Jose A. Dapena handled first-party insurance litigation before he handled anything else. The fee arrangement for an insurance dispute is explained when you call.